Steady Climbers
Every three months, ranks eligible U.S. stocks by past gains compared with daily price swings. Holds up to 20 and changes stocks that no longer qualify.
| Risk | Holding time | For players who want |
|---|---|---|
| Medium | Months | To compare gains with price swings |
How it works
The rule favors past gains with smaller daily price swings.
How it ranks stocks For each eligible stock, divide its gain over 252 trading days by a measure of its daily price swings. Both numbers must be above zero. A higher score ranks first.
What it holds Choose up to 20 stocks. With at least 20 qualifiers, keep selected holdings as they are and add new picks. With fewer, split the money equally across every qualifying stock.
Rechecks at quarter-end. Orders fill at the next trading open. Smaller price swings in the past do not guarantee smaller losses next.
Rules at a glance
- Eligible assets
- Up to 20 qualifying U.S. stocks
- Schedule
- Rechecks and resets at each quarter-end.
- Money split
- Equal shares.
- Automatic loss limit
- None.
| Detail | What it means |
|---|---|
| Holds | Up to 20 qualifying U.S. stocks |
| Style | Ranks gains compared with daily price swings |
| Trade timing | Checks quarter-end closes; trades at the next trading open |
| Money split | With 20 selected, keeps survivors and adds entrants up to 5% each; with fewer, resets to equal shares |
| Risk | Medium |
| Automatic loss limit | None; selection changes at quarter-end |
What to watch out for
- Past stability can end. A stock with smooth earlier gains can still fall sharply. This rule does not judge the quality of the business.
- The rule waits until quarter-end. There is no early sale after a percentage loss. Selected stocks can also come from the same industry.
- Fewer qualifiers mean larger positions. With four qualifying stocks, the target is 25% each. Even with 20 holdings, retained positions can grow above their original weights.
Source
Ranks past price gains against the size of daily price swings.
Full rulebook
1. Strategy overview
- Name: Steady Climbers
- Goal: Hold up to 20 eligible U.S. stocks with the highest positive gains compared with daily price swings. Recheck every three months.
- Idea: Give a higher score to stronger gains and smaller day-to-day variation over the same period.
2. Investments it can hold
- Pool: eligible U.S. common stocks with at least $50 million in average daily dollar trading volume over the last 63 trading days
- Calculate daily dollar volume as closing price multiplied by trading volume, then average those 63 values.
- Minimum price: the signal-date closing price must be at least $5.
- Missing signal-date prices, insufficient history or an unavailable volume screen exclude a stock.
3. Data and schedule
- Data: daily closing prices and trading volume; no company financial data
- History needed: 253 closing prices to calculate 252 daily returns
- First check: the close on the day you start
- Later checks: the final trading close of March, June, September and December
- Trades: at the next trading day's open
4. When it buys
- Calculate the total price return as
(close today / close 252 trading days ago) - 1. - Calculate each of the last 252 daily returns as
(today's close / previous close) - 1. - Measure their variation using sample standard deviation. Subtract their mean from each return, square those differences, add them, divide by 251 and take the square root.
- Keep only stocks whose total return and standard deviation are both available and above zero.
- Divide total return by the standard deviation to get the score. Rank highest first, breaking ties by ticker in alphabetical order.
- Select the top 20, or all qualifiers if fewer than 20 qualify.
- Maximum holdings: 20 stocks
- The first selection follows the same rules, then joins the quarterly schedule.
5. When it sells
- At quarter-end, sell holdings outside the new selected group. This includes stocks that fail eligibility, have a zero or negative total return, have zero or unavailable variation, or rank too low.
- If no stocks qualify, sell every holding and keep cash until a later quarterly check.
- Time limit: none. A stock can remain while it qualifies and stays selected.
6. How it divides the money
- At least 20 qualifiers: select 20. Keep the share count of each selected stock already held. Do not reset those surviving holdings to 5%.
- Each new entrant targets the smaller of 5% of the portfolio or the remaining portfolio share divided equally among new entrants. Unused money stays in cash.
- One to 19 qualifiers: target equal shares across all qualifiers, including existing holdings. With N qualifiers, each gets
100% / N. No empty 5% slots remain in cash. - No qualifiers: target 100% cash.
- Opening-price changes and rounding can leave actual weights different from these targets.
- Dividend cash: can fund new entrants or an equal-share reset. If all 20 holdings survive, their shares stay unchanged and dividend cash can remain uninvested.
- Stop loss: none
- Take profit: none
7. Moon's notes
- The score includes the latest month. It measures price gains without adding dividends.
- This is a gain-to-variation score. It does not subtract a cash return or use company forecasts.
- Dividends on shares held at the previous close enter cash on the ex-dividend date. This is the first day a new buyer no longer qualifies for that dividend, and it can be earlier than payment day.
- Cash earns no interest in this game.